| Gesa Eisle | 1928 |
| Adam Ritter | 1930 |
| Thomas J. Leavy Sr. | 1932 |
| Cataldo Steffanacci | 1935 |
| Andrew Van Der Mass | 1937 |
| Joseph Staudt | 1938 |
| John Van Winkle Sr. | 1941 |
| Cornelius Nederfield | 1941 |
| John Earle | 1947 |
| *LODD* Arthur McPartland *LODD* | 1948 |
| Conrad Noll | 1948 |
| Joseph Quadrio | 1952 |
| Anthony Zanetti | 1952 |
| Joseph Swit | 1954 |
| James Van Houten | 1955 |
| Thomas Steward | 1956 |
| Garret Grieves | 1956 |
| Reverend Joseph Marta | 1958 |
| Thomas Varetoni | 1962 |
| John B. Johnston | 1960 |
| Edward Kirchner | 1961 |
| Stanley V. Kucinski | 1961 |
| Charles Lembeck | 1961 |
| Anthony Meyers | 1962 |
| James Sweeny | 1962 |
| Robert Allen | 1962 |
| Anton Resch | 1962 |
| Peter Brock | 1962 |
| Jacob Wiarda | 1963 |
| Charles Rudolph | 1963 |
| John De Vogel | 1964 |
| William Donkersloot | 1964 |
| Horace G. McComb Sr. | 1965 |
| John Kolbeck | 1966 |
| Stanley Gmyrek | 1966 |
| Louis Battel | 1966 |
| Thomas Johnson Jr. | 1966 |
| Aaron Vander Tulip | 1966 |
| William Orr | 1966 |
| Bart Marchioni | 1967 |
| Peter Celentano | 1970 |
| Frederick W. Fischer | 1971 |
| Peter Van Dorn | 1971 |
| Abe Ven Lenten | 1971 |
| Romolo Zangrando | 1971 |
| Raymond Kazaren | 1971 |
| Arthur Anderson | 1971 |
| Harry Santen | 1972 |
| Robert Taylor | 1974 |
| Clifford Waer | 1974 |
| Ira Van Vliet | 1974 |
| Frank Peterson | 1976 |
| Reverend Thomas Suchon | 1976 |
| George Wiess | 1977 |
| James Johnson | 1977 |
| Marius Celentano | 1979 |
| Henry Zanetti | 1979 |
| Ferdinand Imperato | 1979 |
| Elmer Cowley | 1979 |
| Adrian Corneliese | 1980 |
| Horace G. McComb Jr. | 1980 |
| Fred Piverotto | 1980 |
| Fred Peluso | 1980 |
| Edgar Dolak | 1980 |
| Charles Tuttle | 1981 |
| Charles Colgero | 1981 |
| Vladimir Surgent | 1981 |
| Frank S. Agnello | 1982 |
| Lawrence R. Belfi | 1982 |
| Lawrence Fiori | 1982 |
| John M. Rich | 1982 |
| Peter L. Vander Jagt | 1982 |
| Harold E. Kutner | 1982 |
| Mario Magnoli | 1982 |
| John J. Bradley | 1983 |
| Robert L. Buttel | 1983 |
| John McDonald | 1984 |
| John F. Locher | 1984 |
| Frank Zanet | 1985 |
| Joseph A. Sanson | 1985 |
| George J. Reinhardt | 1986 |
| Percy F. Holtz | 1986 |
| Kenneth T. Herdin | 1986 |
| Gary P. Tonon | 1987 |
| Reverend Leo T. Sweeney | 1988 |
| Daniel Jacobus | 1988 |
| Herbert Van Broekhoven | 1988 |
| Adolph Stickelberger | 1989 |
| Charles Furst | 1989 |
| Fred Van Orden | 1990 |
| John Zanet | 1990 |
| Steven Szabo | 1990 |
| Harvey Dorpfeld | 1991 |
| Alexander Gray | 1991 |
| Edwin Dobkowski | 1991 |
| Walter Eno | 1991 |
| Walter R. Geron | 1991 |
| Edward Freed Sr. | 1991 |
| Barney Viane | 1991 |
| Michael C. Sanfilippo | 1992 |
| William Kenselaar | 1992 |
| Gerald Maxwell | 1993 |
| John Boehm Jr. | 1993 |
| Anthony Lulling | 1993 |
| John Giblock | 1993 |
| John Prosik | 1993 |
| John Goodwin | 1994 |
| John Stone | 1994 |
| Frank Van Orden Jr. | 1994 |
| Rudolph Buchar | 1994 |
| John Decker | 1994 |
| Leopold J. Loder | 1994 |
| Andrew Sesak | 1994 |
| Thomas Boomer | 1995 |
| Henry Meyers | 1996 |
| William Mikolaczyk | 1997 |
| Edward Markovits | 1997 |
| Martin Krupinski | 1998 |
| Kennth L. Hagberg | 1999 |
| Patrick Mullen | 1999 |
| Secretary Lillian Racz | 2000 |
| Joseph Mayer | 2000 |
| Mark Kaiser | 2000 |
| Leroy Saunders | 2000 |
| Henry Vespa | 2000 |
| Peter Vasilik | 2001 |
| Joseph Dobkowski | 2002 |
| Lawrence Budz | 2002 |
| Paut Gitin | 2002 |
| Herbert Birnberg | 2002 |
| William Murin | 2002 |
| Robert Graglia | 2002 |
| Charles Stolarz | 2003 |
| Mario Colli | 2003 |
| Edward Bonnema | 2003 |
| Thomas Korupchak | 2003 |
| Frank Waller | 2003 |
| Gary Bolcar | 2003 |
| Richard Weise | 2003 |
| Rabbi Eugene Markovitz | 2003 |
| Thomas McCann | 2004 |
| Edward Van Winkle | 2004 |
| Steven Zubal | 2005 |
| Joseph Hoffer | 2005 |
| Theodore Rembisz | 2005 |
| Samuel Zubal | 2006 |
| Albert Vaxmonsky | 2006 |
| Edward Van Dorn | 2006 |
| Rabbi Joshua Lefkowitz | 2006 |
| Reverend Fred Tanis Jr. | 2007 |
| Joseph Paccioretti | 2007 |
| George Gernat | 2007 |
| Richard Catanzaro | 2007 |
| Emile Krompasick | 2008 |
| Robert Luciano | 2009 |
| Raymond Ruffillo | 2009 |
| George Hempel | 2009 |
| Mechanic Woodrow Zegers | 2009 |
| James Ridgell | 2010 |
| Stephen Hoholik | 2010 |
| Donald Bakelaar Jr. | 2010 |
| William Speer | 2010 |
| Joseph Sudol | 2010 |
| Daniel Meeks | 2010 |
| Jacob Van Broekhoven | 2010 |
| Salvatore Verga | 2012 |
| Kenneth Salerno | 2012 |
| Sylvio Bettio | 2012 |
| Terry Barszcz | 2013 |
| George Pachuta | 2014 |
| Ernest Relyea | 2014 |
| Stephen Kirrer | 2014 |
| Donald Schwarz | 2014 |
| Ronald Townsley | 2014 |
| Alexander Beattie | 2015 |
| Robert Bonomini | 2015 |
| Steven J. Lendl | 2015 |
| Louis Tufaro | 2015 |
| Joseph S. Colca | 2016 |
| Charles Bolcar Sr. | 2016 |
| Kevin Cooper | 2017 |
| Louis J. Morreale Jr. | 2017 |
| Ronald L. Parker | 2017 |
| Donald E. Muller | 2017 |
| John Clark Seymour | 2017 |
| Richard Murin | 2018 |
| Constantine Demikoff | 2018 |
| James H. Lyons | 2018 |
| Frederick A. Morreale | 2019 |
| Louis R. Graglia | 2019 |
| John Gaudet | 2019 |
| Donald Surgent | 2019 |
| Fred Hrinuk | 2019 |
| William Van Der Wende | 2019 |
| Reverend Earl Modean | 2020 |
| *LODD* John P. Van Dorn Jr. *LODD* | 2020 |
| Reverend Alan Savitt | 2020 |
| Robert Terry | 2021 |
| Gene Costa | 2021 |
| Raymond Bonomini | 2021 |
| John Synovetz | 2021 |
| Donald Mullen | 2021 |
| Anthony Em | 2022 |
| Donald Hamm | 2022 |
| Richard Bonanno | 2022 |
| Dennis Bartolo | 2022 |
| Frank Stolarz | 2022 |
| Donald J. Murray | 2023 |
| Virgil J. DeMario | 2023 |
| Leonard Swan | 2023 |
| Paul F. Passenti Jr. | 2023 |
| William E. Graff | 2023 |
| Joseph Williams Jr. | 2023 |
| Gerald McCann | 2024 |
| Anthony Alessi | 2024 |
| Leonard Passenti Jr. | 2024 |
| Mario DiSoteo | 2025 |
| Brian G. Sieper | 2025 |
| Michael Butts | 2025 |
| Jerry Ference | 2025 |
